13

votes

Vote

home-hobbies in Home & Hobbies Channel,
Written by: Sophie Lecoq on Mar 25 2010, 7:17am

Is this the end of the bookmark industry - again?

Why, why, why?

Why is Nintendo releasing a DS title that contains 100 books? Who wants to read on an NDS screen?

I'm ok with admitting that playing on a hand console is fun. You can take it anywhere, play anytime (no, not in a work meeting Jack) and get rid of any outside noises or noisy people by playing with headphones on.

But doesn't it work the same with a book as far as reading is concerned?

I admit that the price can be a reason, but this is what libraries are for. Or maybe a storage issue that leads you to invest in a small cartridge rather than new bookshelves? Or just simply yet another attempt to pretend you're actually a reader when in fact in you know you'll never get past page 3 of "Alice in Wonderland"?

And who would actually enjoy reading Leo Tolstoi's 1500-page "War and Peace"... on a supersmall screen? Whatever the options the NDS is offering, you'll never get the same feeling of the willing page or that of smelling an old book, or buying one in a flea market and read on its first blank page that it once belonged to Mrs Oldsmith in Iowa.

Finally, I also feel that books are about sharing. Which you can't do with a console. "Here Kate, I've written down something in the margin for you..." Err, huh, well, John, please never write on my NDS again.

Citizens Comments

Pierre VEBER says:

I agree. Even screen readers are today some kind of curiosity for me. I didn't have any problem to get rid of the CDs, but I can't imagine reading my books on a screen... yet :)

4

Votes

Vote
Mar 25 2010, 11:15am | Report

Nacim TAMINE says:

Totally share your point of view, which make me think, are we getting so old that we cannot positively react to innovation? Did our grandparent had the same reaction we they saw us hearing music with earphones?

4

Votes

Vote
Mar 25 2010, 12:09pm | Report

Scott Smith says:

Don't count out the good ol' bookmark. There's innovation to be found in every industry. ;)

5

Votes

Vote
Mar 25 2010, 4:07pm | Report

Pierre VEBER says:

@Scott: excellent! Gotta have one!

4

Votes

Vote
Mar 26 2010, 2:27am | Report

Sophie Lecoq says:

Yeah yeah, I love it!!

4

Votes

Vote
Mar 26 2010, 3:34am | Report

Camille EBLING says:

Not interested, that can be a good idea, but well I prefer to have a book in hands rather to read it on DS.

4

Votes

Vote
Mar 26 2010, 5:17am | Report

Geert MEULENBELT says:

Let's think again. Remember the last time you bought a book. It's kind of expensive isn't it? Now divide the cartridge price by 100 and you get a pretty attractive price per book. It doesn't work for you and me but think about teenagers that read a book per day, and those are not really the books that you would want to keep or share.

Let me find a scapegoat or two and I'll get back to you. One thing I can foresee: there has been so much hammering, writing and scraping on those ND screens (thanks Mario Bross!) that reading text may be tough. 

 

 

 

4

Votes

Vote
Mar 26 2010, 8:58am | Report

Benoit OLIVAIN says:

I am sceptic with this "technology".   Are people ready for this? We'll see pretty soon. I think iPad can be a great tool to read some magazines with the "big screen" (wording, taglines, and photos), but I don't know regarding books and DS. Personnaly, I like computer, mobiles and "regular books".

4

Votes

Vote
Mar 30 2010, 2:11am | Report

Xavier BILLARD says:

Read a book with a DS for me is not possible. First the screen is too small may be the iPad is the good device. But me I prefer a real book when I take my train every day, I'm sure I would have no problem with battery. I love to see the book cover and store it in my library.  

4

Votes

Vote
Mar 30 2010, 6:29am | Report

Nacim TAMINE says:

Saw last comments..Okay now I'm pretty sure w e are getting too old for innovation!

0

Votes

Vote
Apr 9 2010, 2:01pm | Report

Tim Browning says:

Whilst not perfect (and nothing beats a proper book), reading on an electronic device does have its benefits ... Firstly, you dont have to carry the book about with you, in addition to your electronic device (in my case, my phone has e-reader software on it) and secondly, you can read in bed without disturbing your partner - no need to have the light on and no noise as you turn the page!

0

Votes

Vote
Apr 21 2010, 8:09am | Report

Post your comment

default Avatar

You might be interested in these related contributions

SoftCity Promotion

About the Author

Sophie Lecoq

Paris, Ile-de-France, FR

137 contributions

I am happy to do anything that makes me happy.

software social commerce